It’s a story that goes back a decade, and has never before been told publicly. It involves several veteran CIA officers, an undercover mission and a huge haul of extremely valuable intelligence. The saga shows just how intense the competition between major accounting firms is, and just how willing they can be to engage in tactics that don’t exactly mesh with their buttoned-down corporate image.
Flash back 10 years. At the time, Deloitte was not the major player in federal consulting it is today. „Deloitte had fits and starts in trying to do the federal business,“ recalls a former Deloitte partner who asked not to be named. „In ’05 and ’06, Deloitte was doing maybe $300 million a year in revenue and had maybe 1,000 people.“ The former partner says the firm had a lofty internal goal of getting its federal business to the billion-dollar level. „They wanted to do an acquisition, but they weren’t sure which one.“
Then, in early 2007, a phone rang inside Deloitte. On the line was a source, passing on some valuable information. BearingPoint, the struggling consulting firm, had just called an emergency meeting. BearingPoint partners from around the world would be coming to a hastily scheduled session at the convention center in Orlando, Florida. The source didn’t know why the meeting was scheduled. It was a complete mystery. But Deloitte’s managers were prepared to go to unusual lengths to unravel it.
Deloitte had an internal team to call on in just such a moment. Although its name changed over time, the group was generally known as the competitive intelligence unit, and it was led by a trim former CIA officer with piercing eyes named Gordon „Gordy“ Welch. His number two was John Shumadine, who had served as an economist for the CIA and, like his boss Welch, was an Army veteran.
Collectors and analysts
The two (2) CIA officers oversaw a team at Deloitte that was divided into two main categories: collectors and analysts. Collectors uncovered information that could be valuable to Deloitte’s senior managers. Analysts poured through that information, combined it with other known facts and developed narratives about what they thought was going on behind the scenes in the offices of Deloitte’s clients and customers.
„Our job was to spy on Ernst & Young, Price Waterhouse Coopers, KPMG and some of the consulting competitors,“ said a person who worked in the unit. „We were trying to steal their pricing models, how they determined discounts, and especially new product lines or service lines.“ The team developed networks of ex-employees as sources and traveled to trade shows to gather information.
The competitive intelligence unit was part of a larger umbrella group called Deloitte Intelligence. That group included two related efforts. One was called „market intelligence“ and focused on gathering details about companies that could be useful for its customers and could help Deloitte win new business.
The last piece of the team was known as „win/loss.“ That group conducted after-action reports on efforts to win major accounts to determine what had gone right — or wrong — with each sales pitch.As a result, the Deloitte Intelligence team was a mixture of former government spies and accounting industry veterans. By several accounts, there were tensions inside Deloitte about how far the intelligence team would be allowed to go, with some employees on the team pushing for a more aggressive approach and other forces inside Deloitte preaching restraint.
The team included at least three former CIA officers, a former Secret Service officer, a former IRS agent, an employee who wrote spy novel, and one who had a side business selling Kente cloth Polo shirts. When the call from the source came in, nearly all of them went into action.They stood up a full time office in at Deloitte’s offices in suburban Virginia, where managers and analysts could coordinate the operation. Deloitte officials also checked in with the firm’s general counsel to sort out what they would be legally permitted to do.
With the analysts in place, it came time to select the collectors — the actual on-the-ground agents who would book hotel rooms near BearingPoint’s meeting at the Orlando convention center and spend several days trying to figure out what was going on.
Two (2) collectors were assigned the job. The first was a woman named Abby Vietor, a Deloitte employee who had earlier worked at a private investigative firm called Diligence LLC. The second was a man who would later go on to significant fame and controversy: John Kiriakou, a Deloitte employee and former CIA case officer who had served in various capacities for the spy agency in Bahrain, Athens and at CIA headquarters in Langley, Virginia.
In early 2007, Kiriakou was simply a collector for Deloitte’s corporate intelligence unit, and he was on his way to Orlando to try to piece together what the BearingPoint partners were up to.
On the ground, the two Deloitte employees assessed the situation. BearingPoint was clearly in crisis mode, and the firm’s partners appeared in to be disarray. This offered an opportunity for the two collectors from Deloitte: At various points over the coming days, the two Deloitte employees walked in and out of the convention center and stationed themselves at a bar, picking up scraps of conversation from the distraught BearingPoint partners.
According to a person familiar with the operation, the two agents also spent a considerable amount of time in the men’s and women’s bathrooms — hiding out to avoid detection, and taking notes on conversations they overheard. „You can’t believe what people will say while they’re in there,“ said a person who participated in the operation.
They were in regular communication with the team in Virginia, emailing snippets of gossip and information that they were picking up. At the Deloitte offices, analysts raced to their computers to check details, confirm facts or issue „taskings“ to the Deloitte agents in the field to try to pin down specific details. „When the news came through that they had gotten some information, we stopped what we were doing and focused on it,“ said a second person who participated in the operation. „This turned out to be a significant feat.“
That’s because the agents on the ground uncovered a valuable piece of intelligence. BearingPoint’s financial situation was dire. And as a result, the partners were considering selling the firm’s federal practice — a business that could be a perfect solution to Deloitte’s own problems in the federal space. But how much was BearingPoint’s federal practice actually worth? That would depend on key details such as whom the firm’s clients were and how much those clients were paying every year.
Then Deloitte‚s agents in the field made a breakthrough: They learned that senior BearingPoint officers were holding a break-out session, and they figured out the location for the high-level meeting. Deloitte’s team decided that any paperwork the BearingPoint managers left behind would be fair game for the agents to pick up — but only after several hours had passed, making it clear that the material had been officially abandoned.
The Deloitte operatives staked out the empty meeting space for hours after the BearingPoint executives left, pacing the halls. At one point, an operative shooed away a cleaning crew that was on its way into the space. Once they decided enough time had passed, they entered the room.Inside, they hit pay dirt: The BearingPoint executives, perhaps distracted by the financial calamity facing their firm, had left behind notes and documents that the Deloitte operatives viewed as the key to unlocking the mystery of the value of the federal practice. „They left revenue projections, source intelligence,“ said a person who participated in the operation. „It was like the holy grail of the BearingPoint business.“
The second person who participated in the operation said that the ground team also obtained breakdowns of the revenues generated by specific accounts. The Deloitte collectors scooped up everything they could find, and headed out to a nearby Kinko’s to fax it directly to the analysts in Virginia, who could begin teasing out the full implications.
People involved in the operation say the intelligence gathered in Orlando gave Deloitte a leg up in understanding just how valuable BearingPoint’s federal business could be, despite the financial difficulty facing the overall firm. A former partner who was not involved in the Orlando operation described the potential acquisition this way: „They had accounts that would have taken years for Deloitte to develop. Relationships at the Department of Defense and the Department of Homeland Security and other institutions. It was a huge opportunity.“
It wasn’t until March 2009 that Deloitte was able to take advantage of that opportunity. That month, Deloitte announced it would buy BearingPoint’s North American public services unit for $350 million in cash as BearingPoint worked through a bankruptcy. Despite the success of the operation in Orlando, people familiar with Deloitte’s intelligence team say the unit was wound down over the following years, its employees leaving for other firms and other careers. Only a small number are still employed at Deloitte.